Tuesday, March 25, 2025

Level 3; the Riot at Pompeii (Tacitus: XIV.17); it’s only a game?

This is the account to which below refers: the riot and bloodshed at the amphitheatre of Pompeii (AD59) reported by the Roman historian Tacitus. When dealing with an original Latin text, word order will become a major player, and so I have broken it up into clauses and phrases and then matched them with the English translation.

(1)

[1] Sub idem tempus ¦ [2] levī initiō ¦ [3] atrōx caedēs orta ¦ [3] inter colōnōs Nucerīnōs Pompēiānōsque ¦ [4] gladiātōriō spectāculō ¦ [5] quod Livinēius Rēgulus, ¦ [6] quem mōtum senātū rettulī, ¦ edēbat.

[1] At about the same time ¦ [2] from a trivial beginning ¦ [3] arose terrible carnage / bloodshed ¦ [4] between the inhabitants of Nucernia and Pompeii ¦ [4] at a gladiatorial show ¦ [5] which Livineius Regulus ¦ (6) whom, as I have related, had been expelled from the Senate ¦ was staging.

caedēs, -is [3/f]: slaughter; massacre; carnage; some translations of atrōx caedēs are less dramatic e.g. “serious affray” and “serious trouble”, but caedēs is stronger than that, suggesting bloodshed and killing i.e. it wasn’t just a spot of "trouble" because it reached the Senate and Tacitus wrote about it.

ēdō (with long /ē/), -ere, ēdidī [3]: give out; produce; publish (from which there are the English derivatives editor and edition); here it is referring to games organised, and presumably financed, by Livineius; Note: edō (with short /e/), -ere, ēdī [3]: eat

īdem [m], eadem [f], idem [n]: the same

levis, -e: light, trivial, trifling

mōtus, -a, -um: (literally) moved; mōtum senatū: expelled from the Senate

ortus, -a, -um: having arisen

referō, referre, retulī: (here) report; relate

(2) This section starts, in a sense, no differently from a football match nowadays where the rival fans are shouting at each other, but it soon turns nasty …

[1] quippe oppidānā lascīviā ¦ [2] in vicem incessentēs probra, ¦ [3] dein saxa, ¦ [4] postrēmō ferrum sūmpsēre, ¦ [5] validiōre Pompēiānōrum plēbe, ¦ [6] apud quōs spectāculum edēbātur.

[1] For with unruliness typical of townsfolk ¦ [2] hurling abuse in turns / at each other ¦ [3] they then took up stones ¦ [4] and finally weapons ¦ [5] with the people of Pompeii being / proving to be the stronger [i.e. the Pompeians had the upper hand] ¦ [6] where (literally: among whom / in whose presence) the show was being staged

ferrum, -ī [2/n]: iron, but can refer to any metal tool including a weapon or a sword

incessō, -ere, incessīvī [3]: assault; attack; abuse

invicem or in vicem: in turns; alternately

lascivia, -ae [1/f]: can be positive i.e. playfulness, or negative: wantonness; Tacitus writes that the incident grew from a trivial beginning (levī intiō) and so, possibly, what simply began as light-hearted “pot-shots” got out of hand

probrum, -ī [2/n]: insult; abuse

quippe: used to introduce an explanation or cause i.e. for, indeed, in fact

sūmpsēre = sūmpsērunt: they took (up) < sūmō, -ere, sūmpsī [3]: take

validus, -a, -um: strong; comparative: validior, -ius: stronger

(3)

[1] ergō ¦ [3] dēportātī sunt in urbem ¦ (2) multī ē Nucerīnīs ¦ [4] truncō per vulnera corpore, [5] ac plērīque līberōrum aut parentum mortīs dēflēbant.

[1] Therefore, ¦ (2) many of the Nucerians ¦ [3] were carried to the city ¦ [4] their bodies maimed through wounds ¦ [5] and most of them were lamenting the deaths of parents or children.

dēfleō, -ēre, dēflēvō [2]: weep / cry over; lament

dēportō, -āre, -āvī [1]: (here) convey; carry

truncus, -a, -um: mutilated; maimed

(4)

[2] cuius reī iūdicium ¦ [1] prīnceps ¦ [3] senātuī, ¦ [4] senātus cōnsulibus permīsit. [5] et rūrsus rē ad patrēs relātā, [6] prohibitī ¦ [8] pūblicē in decem annōs ¦ [7] eius modī coetū ¦ Pompēiānī ¦ [9] collēgiaque ¦ [10] quae contrā lēgēs īnstituerant ¦ dissolūta;

[1] The emperor delegated ¦ [2] judgement of this matter ¦ [3] to the Senate, (and) ¦ [4] the Senate to the consuls. [5] And the matter having again been referred back to the Senators, ¦ [6] the inhabitants of Pompeii were barred ¦ [7] from a gathering of this type ¦ [8] in public for ten years, ¦ [9] and associations ¦ [10] which they had formed against the law ¦ were dissolved.

collēgium, -ī [2/n]: association; society

coetus, -ūs [4/m]: meeting; gathering; Pompēiānī … coetū … prohibitī (sunt) │ The Pompeians were barred from (any) gathering

īnstituō, -ere, īnstituī [3]: establish; set up

patrēs: refers to patrēs concrīptī; literally: conscript fathers, the term used to refer to members of the Senate

(rūrsus) relātus, -a, -um: (here) having been referred back

(5)

[1] Livinēius et ¦ [2] quī aliī ¦ [3] sēditiōnem concīverant ¦ [4] exiliō multātī sunt.

[1] Livineius and ¦ [2] those others who ¦ [3] had provoked the riot ¦ [4] were punished with exile.

concieō, -ēre, concīvī [2]: provoke

multō, -āre, -āvī [1]: punish

sēditiō, sēditiōnis [3/f]: rebellion; riot; uprising